Is Our Toplist a true reflection....

admin

Retired Administrator
Top 25 episode by rating1102 Red DressSeason 14.74 (171 Vote(s))2518 Dewey's Special ClassSeason 54.69 (134 Vote(s))3221 Malcolm vs. ReeseSeason 24.68 (126 Vote(s))4420 Baby (1)Season 44.67 (119 Vote(s))5113 RollerskatesSeason 14.66 (142 Vote(s))6522 Reese Joins The Army (2)Season 54.66 (140 Vote(s))7505 Malcolm Films ReeseSeason 54.66 (122 Vote(s))8219 Tutoring ReeseSeason 24.65 (134 Vote(s))9315 Hal's BirthdaySeason 34.65 (118 Vote(s))10202 Halloween ApproximatelySeason 24.63 (153 Vote(s))11321 CliquesSeason 34.63 (122 Vote(s))12403 Family ReunionSeason 44.62 (131 Vote(s))13208 TherapySeason 24.62 (129 Vote(s))14217 SurgerySeason 24.62 (125 Vote(s))15508 Block PartySeason 54.62 (125 Vote(s))16210 BullySeason 24.61 (132 Vote(s))17421 Baby (2)Season 44.61 (116 Vote(s))18115 SmundaySeason 14.60 (134 Vote(s))19322 MonkeySeason 34.60 (129 Vote(s))20302 Emancipation (2)Season 34.60 (122 Vote(s))21308 PokerSeason 34.60 (122 Vote(s))22515 Reese's ApartmentSeason 54.59 (130 Vote(s))23213 New NeighboursSeason 24.59 (127 Vote(s))24316 Hal CoachesSeason 34.59 (122 Vote(s))25415 Garage SaleSeason 44.59 (120 Vote(s))What do people thing as regards our toplist, has it got it right? Whats in their that shouldn't be and what are you dissappointed thats not in their

If you haven't already. remember to rate all the episodes at the MITMVC, and you can easily affect the position of some of these episodes, even a 0.01 swing could drop them 3 or 4 places.
 

allison

New member
Some of these episodes are my favourites (Tutoring Reese, Malcolm vs Reese, Bully etc) and some of them I didn´t like that much (like Dewey´s special class or Reese´s appartment). But that´s of course just my personal opinion. I´m not sure if the list really reflects all members´ opinions, because some episodes (which lots of people liked, I think) are missing. I think If boys were girls and Dewey´s dog are quite popular episodes, but they aren´t rated very well compared to other episodes. And you´re right about one thing: Even one vote, which could be a 0.01 swing, could drop an episode 3 or 4 places. So if a single person can affect the position of an episode that much, it can´t actually reflect the opinion of all or most users. And most people probably don´t rate every episode. One example: Cynthia´s back is rated very badly. But still 150 people rated the episode and 13% even gave it 5 stars. That´s more than 15 people (if I did the math correctly^^"). Kitty´s back is rated much better (4 stars) but only 31 people voted and 46% gave 5 stars. That´s even less than 15 votes, but still it´s ranked way better than Cynthia´s back because less people voted.
I think I explained my theory in a very confusing way, but I hope you can still understand what I mean. :D
 

Wemboy

New member
Yeh i know what you mean allison, it's not exactly a scientific way of rating the episodes. Never going to happen, but say if only one person voted and gave an episode five stars, would that send it straight to the top? Still, it seems to work for the most part, i like all the episodes i've seen on the top 25 list. A little surprised to see rollerskates so high though, i like it but wouldn't have it in my top five. I really am baffled by the absence of bowling though, in my view it's the best episode of them all. I guess red dress just has more staying power than any other episode, everyone loves it to be fair. There seems to be quite a spread of episodes across the series' aswell, i expected it to be more weighted to seasons one and two.
 

admin

Retired Administrator
its quite difficult to move stuff in and out of the toplist currently, but there are border line episodes which could be pushed in or out.

Has anyone noticed the total lack of a season 6 episode in the toplist :D?
 

Gouki

New member
There are some really great episodes in that list, but like wemboy said, some great episodes are also missing.

Things like this are always sort of ineffective--I don't mean that in a bad way, but you'll get as many people who want to rate the episodes properly as fangirls/boys who want to rate it on how hot the boys look.

Maybe I'm just being bitter based on other series though.
 

Emrysgirl

New member
Yeah, I too would put Bowling high in the list.
Also, I'm surprised FowardsBackwards isn't there.:confused:

Otherwise, pretty good!:)
 
Top